This Manly Bands review answers the question most people type after the name: is Manly Bands legit? It is a real company. Manly Bands, LLC is a Utah maker of men’s wedding bands, in business since 2016, with published prices, a 30-day return window and a lifetime warranty on manufacturing defects, and most of its Trustpilot reviewers are happy. Its record also has weak points that its own pages do not mention: a D- rating from the Better Business Bureau, one exchange and no more, rings in tungsten and titanium that cannot be resized, and a federal copyright case brought by another Utah ring maker that was still open on 18 September 2026. Every policy, price, rating and court filing below was opened that day.
How we researched. Nothing here was bought, tested or sent to us: it is researched, not tested.
What is on this page11 sections
Key Takeaways
- Manly Bands, LLC was incorporated in Utah on 4 November 2016, per the BBB. The BBB rates it D-, not accredited, citing 9 complaints the company did not respond to.
- You get 30 days from delivery to return a ring for a refund, or to exchange it once. Not both, and not twice.
- Tungsten, titanium, cobalt chrome and inlaid rings cannot be resized. Only gold and platinum can, per its own sizing page.
- Trustpilot shows 4.1 from 243 reviews on a claimed profile that invites buyers to review; 23% are one star.
- Diamonds Direct, L.C., which trades as Lashbrook, sued Manly Bands for copyright infringement in December 2023 over ring designs and product photos. The case was stayed for a settlement conference in May 2026, with no judgment on the docket.
Manly Bands at a Glance
Our verdict: a real Utah maker, with one exchange and a weak complaint record
Manly Bands
by Manly Bands
Best for: A buyer who wants an unusual inlay or licensed design, knows his size, and has at least two months before the wedding.
Manly Bands, LLC sells in its own name from Utah; the BBB rates it D- and not accredited, and its tungsten, titanium and ceramic rings cannot be resized, so the 30-day exchange is the only size fix.
Illustration of the setting type, not a photo of this ring.
What we like
- Publishes prices on every ring, from 40-dollar silicone to solid gold and platinum
- 30 days from delivery to return for a refund, with free standard shipping in the US
- Lifetime warranty on manufacturing defects, with a claims portal
Keep in mind
- Only one exchange, and a return or an exchange, not both
- Engraved rings are final sale on its returns page
- BBB rating of D-, which the BBB puts down to 9 complaints it did not respond to
- Price range
- $40 to $3,200, from a silicone band to a platinum build-your-own band (checked 18/09/2026)
- Material
- Online, from Lindon, Utah; tungsten, titanium, ceramic, silicone, gold and platinum men's bands, many with inlays
- Guarantee
- 30 days from delivery to return or exchange once; lifetime warranty against manufacturing defects
Who Manly Bands Is
Manly Bands’ About page tells a founders’ story: John and Michelle started the company after a bad experience buying John’s wedding band, founded it in Florida in 2016, and later moved to Utah. The same page says many of its rings are “handcrafted by our amazing staff” in Lindon, Utah, and that production uses “a combination of domestic and international production partners depending on the ring style and material”. It has one showroom, at its office in Lindon.
The BBB profile adds the legal details. Manly Bands, LLC was incorporated on 4 November 2016, lists Marshall Smith as president, and gives an address in Orem, Utah. A 2023 court complaint against the company names Johnathan Ruggiero and Michelle Luchese as its co-founders and co-CEOs.
What It Sells, and What the Metal Is
Manly Bands sells men’s bands in tungsten, titanium, black ceramic, silicone, gold and platinum, and much of the catalog carries an inlay: wood, whiskey barrel wood, meteorite, dinosaur bone, or material from licensed brands such as Jeep and Jack Daniel’s. Its build-your-own bands let you pick the metal, width and finish. A few lines on its product pages deserve a careful read.
Gold-Colored Is Not Always Gold
Its yellow gold collection mixes solid gold with plated tungsten. The CEO, listed there, is described on its own page as “14k Yellow Gold Plated Tungsten”; The Knight, on the same list, is solid 10k or 14k gold. The warranty says plating “will wear over time”. Our guide to black and colored bands explains why a coating wears where solid color does not.
Nickel: Read the Page for Your Ring
The Baller, a black tungsten band, says its tungsten carbide is “cobalt-free” and, in the next sentence, “Our tungsten is NOT nickel-free.” The Maverick, a titanium band, says titanium “contains no nickel”. The gray tungsten build-your-own page we read says nothing about nickel either way. If you react to nickel, ask in writing before ordering, or start from our hypoallergenic wedding bands comparison.
A Scratch Claim That Contradicts Its Warranty
Its platinum build-your-own page carries a line that “tungsten doesn’t scratch”. Its warranty says tungsten is “scratch resistant but not scratch proof” and that scratches are normal wear, not covered. The warranty is the text that binds.
What Can and Cannot Be Resized
Its Find My Size page answers this with a table, reduced here to the answer:
| Material | Can it be resized? | What Manly Bands offers instead |
|---|---|---|
| Gold (10K/14K) | Yes“±2-3 sizes typically” | A jeweler resize |
| Platinum | Yes“±2 sizes typically” | A jeweler resize |
| Titanium, tungsten, cobalt chrome, carbon fiber | No | “30-day size exchange” |
| Meteorite, dinosaur bone or wood inlay | No | “30-day size exchange” |
| Silicone | Not applicable, “Stretches slightly” | Reorder |
The Policies, in Its Own Words
| Policy | What Manly Bands writes | Page |
|---|---|---|
| Returns | “30 days from the date of delivery to return your ring for a full refund back to your original form of payment” | Returns & Exchanges |
| Return shipping | A return shipping fee applies “if you have not opted into Redo package protection” | Returns & Exchanges |
| Exchanges | “You may process ONE exchange during your first 30 days of ownership.” | Returns & Exchanges |
| Return or exchange | “you cannot do both” | Returns & Exchanges |
| Condition | Rings must be “clean, ‘unworn,’ and salable”; a damage fee may be charged | Returns & Exchanges |
| Engraved rings | “FINAL SALE and may NOT be returned OR exchanged” | Returns & Exchanges |
| Silicone rings | Final sale for refunds, exchangeable within 30 days | Returns & Exchanges |
| International orders | No exchanges; return “for store credit and re-purchase” | Returns & Exchanges |
| Warranty | “lifetime manufacturing warranty on any purchased ring for all manufacturing defects” | Warranty |
| Not covered | “loss, theft, weight loss/gain, or normal wear and tear”; scratches count as normal wear | Warranty |
| Warranty claims | “only 1 warranty claim per ring unless the issue is a consistent manufacturing defect” | Warranty |
| Shipping | Free standard shipping, 5 to 7 business days; made-to-order rings take about 4 to 6 weeks first | Shipping |
One Exchange, Then You Are Done
The exchange is the only fix for a wrong size on most of its catalog, and it happens once. Manly Bands tells buyers to check their size with its plastic sizer before using it, “as we offer only one exchange.” If the second ring is also wrong, the policy has no third step. On gold and platinum rings, an exchange may also cost the difference if metal prices have moved.
Engraving: Two Pages, Two Rules
The returns page says engraved rings cannot be returned or exchanged. The product pages we read, including The Maverick and the titanium build-your-own band, say engraved rings are final sale “but we’ll let you exchange it once within 30 days” for a fee of 30 dollars. Engraving adds 25 dollars. If you are unsure of the size, order the ring plain, as the returns page itself advises, and engrave later.
Order Protection and the Return Fee
The returns page names one paid add-on, Redo package protection. Without it, a return for a refund carries a return shipping fee; with it, the protection charge itself is not refunded. The page gives neither price, and we did not go through checkout to see one. One Trustpilot reviewer wrote of paying 18 dollars for “easy returns”; another saw about 55 dollars added at checkout, which Manly Bands, replying, called its Redo Order Protection, an optional service that can be removed before the order ships.
Warranty: Defects Only
The lifetime warranty covers manufacturing defects and nothing about loss, theft or a change in finger size. Rings with gold, platinum, silver, meteorite or stones must be sent back for a claim, repair by anyone else voids the warranty, and silicone rings get one year. Loss and theft need separate insurance.
Prices, Read on Real Product Pages
We read these pages from a US server on 18 September 2026. Prices are as shown before any discount code.
| Ring, read 18/09/2026 | What it is | Price shown |
|---|---|---|
| The Best Man | Silicone band | 40 dollars |
| The Baller | Black-plated tungsten; 4, 6 or 8mm | 250 dollars |
| The CEO | 14k yellow gold plated tungsten; 6 or 8mm | 270 dollars |
| Tungsten, Titanium or Black Ceramic Build Your Own Band | Choice of width and finish | 400 dollars each |
| The Maverick | 8mm titanium with an F-14 Tomcat metal inlay | 450 dollars |
| The Knight | 6mm solid gold (10k or 14k) or platinum | 560 to 2,020 dollars, by option; 810 shown by default |
| Platinum Build Your Own Band | 4 to 8mm | 740 to 3,200 dollars, by option |
| The Manly Ring Sizer | Plastic sizer, sizes 5 to 20 | 10 dollars |
| Engraving | Added to a ring | 25 dollars |
A banner that day offered “25% off Most Popular Styles” with a code, excluding precious metal rings and requiring a 150-dollar minimum. Its discounts are the subject of one of the lawsuits described below. If money is tight, our cheap men’s wedding bands comparison sets several sellers’ return and sizing terms side by side.
What Customers Say, Counted
We read Manly Bands’ Trustpilot and BBB profiles on 18 September 2026, and all 68 of its one- and two-star Trustpilot reviews.
| Source, read 18/09/2026 | Manly Bands |
|---|---|
| Trustpilot score and reviews | 4.1 from 243 reviews; 86 in the last 12 months |
| Trustpilot five stars / one star | 68% / 23% |
| Trustpilot labels | Claimed profile since January 2023; “Paid Trustpilot subscription”; “Asks customers to review” |
| Trustpilot replies | “Replied to 41% of negative reviews” |
| BBB rating and accreditation | D-, not accredited; reason given: “Failure to respond to 9 complaint(s)” |
| BBB complaints | 9 in the last three years, 3 closed in the last 12 months |
| BBB customer reviews | Average of 1.5 from 18 reviews |
| Reviews on its own site | 28,748 reviews averaging about 4.7, collected by Manly Bands itself |
What the 68 Low Trustpilot Reviews Are About
We sorted each one-star and two-star review by its main complaint. The reviews run from August 2022 to September 2026.
| Main complaint | Reviews |
|---|---|
| The ring broke, scratched, lost its plating or its inlay, or arrived damaged | 19 |
| Late delivery, orders not shipped, no updates | 18 |
| Fit, the one-exchange limit, return fees and refunds | 17 |
| Not as pictured, or sold cheaper elsewhere, per the reviewer | 7 |
| Could not reach a person | 3 |
| Marketing emails | 2 |
| A review not published on its site | 1 |
| A discount code missed at checkout | 1 |
Three patterns stand out. Seven reviews describe an inlay coming apart, breaking or discoloring, among them wood, whiskey barrel and abalone shell, which our guide to men’s wedding band styles treats as the risk an inlay brings. Six say the ring did not fit after following its sizer or its sizing advice. And four reviewers wrote that a critical review they left on the Manly Bands site never appeared, so read its on-site average as the brand’s own collection, not an independent count. On the other side, Trustpilot’s own summary of recent reviews says buyers praise the unique styles and the prices.
The BBB Record
The rating is the part to weigh. The BBB lists 9 complaints in three years and gives the company’s failure to respond to 9 of them as the reason for the D-. All five complaints published on the page are marked “Unanswered”; the most recent, dated 30 August 2026, says a ring ordered on 11 June had not shipped and the phone number did not work. On Trustpilot in August 2026, Manly Bands wrote about its phone lines: “I made the call to turn them off in early June,” adding that it was rebuilding them.
The Lawsuits on File
We searched the federal court dockets on CourtListener and opened each filing we cite. A complaint is one side’s allegations, not a finding.
- Diamonds Direct, L.C. dba Lashbrook v. Manly Bands LLC and others, US District Court for the District of Utah, No. 2:23-cv-00870, filed 1 December 2023. Lashbrook, a ring maker that once supplied Manly Bands, alleges that Manly Bands copied its copyrighted ring designs and used its product photos with the watermark removed, and it names Ruggiero, Luchese and Smith as defendants too. On 18 November 2024, Judge Ann Marie McIff Allen dismissed most of the amended complaint, including the ring-design infringement claims, and let the claims over the product photos go on. In January 2025 the court allowed Lashbrook to file a second amended complaint, which it did against all four defendants, and Manly Bands answered it. A May 2026 order sums up the claims as copying of Lashbrook’s designs and product images and removal or falsification of its copyright information. On 18 May 2026 the case was stayed for a court settlement conference, and the docket showed no final judgment when we read it.
- Nadal and Favela v. Manly Bands LLC, US District Court for the Southern District of California, No. 3:25-cv-03133, filed 13 November 2025. The proposed class action alleged that its “limited time” sales never end and its crossed-out reference prices are fictitious. The plaintiffs filed a notice of voluntary dismissal on 6 January 2026.
- Davalos v. Manly Bands LLC, US District Court for the Central District of California, No. 5:25-cv-00996, filed 23 April 2025. The proposed class action alleged marketing text messages sent before 8 a.m., under the Telephone Consumer Protection Act. It was voluntarily dismissed on 16 May 2025.
We did not find a court ruling against Manly Bands on the merits in any of the three.
Who Manly Bands Suits
| Your situation | Manly Bands? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| You want an inlay or a licensed design | A good fit | Inlays and licensed collections are much of its catalog |
| You are unsure of your size | Measure twice first | One exchange only; tungsten and titanium cannot be resized |
| Your wedding is under two months away | Skip made-to-order, or buy elsewhere | Made-to-order rings take about 4 to 6 weeks before shipping |
| You work with your hands | Consider silicone | See our wedding bands for work |
| You want engraving | Order it plain, engrave later | Its returns page makes engraved rings final sale |
| You want solid gold | Check the metal line | Some gold-colored rings are plated tungsten |
| You are choosing a width | Size for it | Our men’s wedding band width guide explains the fit |
Before you order, measure with a plastic sizer at different times of day, using our men’s ring size chart to check the result. Every store we have looked at is listed in our jeweler reviews.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Manly Bands a Reputable Company?
It is a real, established company, but not a spotless one. Manly Bands, LLC has sold men’s bands from Utah since 2016 and scores 4.1 on Trustpilot. Against that, the BBB rates it D- for leaving complaints unanswered, and 23% of its Trustpilot reviews are one star, mostly about quality, delays and fit.
What Are the Allegations in the Manly Bands Lawsuit?
The open case is Lashbrook’s, in federal court in Utah since December 2023: it alleges copied ring designs and product photos with watermarks stripped, and it was paused for settlement talks in May 2026. Two California class actions, over never-ending sales and early-morning marketing texts, were voluntarily dismissed without a ruling.
Are Ridge or Manly Bands Better?
We cannot rank them, because Ridge’s site blocked our US server on 18 September 2026 and we compare only pages we read. On Manly Bands’ side, you get 30 days to return or exchange once, a lifetime defects warranty and no resizing on tungsten or titanium. Ask Ridge the same three questions before choosing.
Are Manly Bands or Gentlebands Better?
On Trustpilot, Manly Bands rates higher: 4.1 from 243 reviews, against 3.3 from 263 for gentlebands.com, whose one-star share was 42% on 18 September 2026. The gentlebands site blocked our US server that day, so we did not compare its return, sizing or warranty terms, which matter more than a score.
Do Manly Bands Run True to Size?
Manly Bands does not promise that they do. Its sizing page tells buyers between sizes to size down for standard fit and up for comfort fit, and six of its 68 low Trustpilot reviews say a ring did not fit after following its advice. With one exchange, measure with a plastic sizer first.
Sources
- Manly Bands, Returns & Exchanges, undated, accessed 18/09/2026.
- Manly Bands, Lifetime Manufacturing Warranty, undated, accessed 18/09/2026.
- Manly Bands, Shipping, undated, accessed 18/09/2026.
- Manly Bands, Find My Size, resizing by material, undated, accessed 18/09/2026.
- Manly Bands, About Us, undated, accessed 18/09/2026.
- Manly Bands, Customer Reviews, store-wide review count, accessed 18/09/2026.
- Manly Bands, Affiliate Partner Program Terms & Conditions, undated, accessed 18/09/2026.
- Manly Bands product pages, prices and product text: The Baller, The CEO, The Knight, The Maverick, Tungsten, Titanium, Black Ceramic and Platinum Build Your Own Band, The Manly Ring Sizer and Silicone Rings, accessed 18/09/2026.
- Better Business Bureau, Manly Bands, LLC, Business Profile, including complaints and customer reviews, accessed 18/09/2026.
- Trustpilot, Manly Bands Reviews, all 68 one- and two-star reviews, accessed 18/09/2026.
- Trustpilot, gentlebands.com Reviews, accessed 18/09/2026.
- CourtListener, Diamonds Direct v. Manly Bands, D. Utah No. 2:23-cv-00870: complaint (2023), memorandum decision on the motion to dismiss (2024) and orders of 18 May 2026, accessed 18/09/2026.
- CourtListener, Nadal v. Manly Bands LLC, S.D. Cal. No. 3:25-cv-03133, complaint (2025) and docket, accessed 18/09/2026.
- CourtListener, Andrew Davalos v. Manly Bands LLC, C.D. Cal. No. 5:25-cv-00996, complaint (2025) and docket, accessed 18/09/2026.