This With Clarity review answers the question behind most searches for the name: is With Clarity legit? On the evidence we could check, yes. With Clarity Inc is a New York jeweler, started in 2015, accredited by the Better Business Bureau with an A+ rating, with a showroom in SoHo, free insured returns within 30 days and prices published for every metal. Three terms deserve a careful read before you pay: its home preview charges 200 dollars per replica ring and refunds it as a gift card, a resize ends the right to return, and its lifetime warranty leaves out the center stone. Every policy, price and rating below was opened on 18 September 2026 and is quoted rather than paraphrased.
How we researched. Nothing on this page was bought, tested or sent to us: it is researched, not tested.
What is on this page10 sections
Key Takeaways
- With Clarity Inc sells in its own name. The BBB lists it as started in May 2015 and accredited since May 2018, with an A+ rating, 8 complaints in three years and an average of 4.71 from 31 customer reviews.
- Returns are free within the US for 30 calendar days from receipt, but a ring “submitted for resizing” cannot be returned, even inside those 30 days.
- The home preview sends up to two replica rings for 7 days. Its page is titled “for Free”; its terms charge 200 dollars per ring and give the money back as a gift card.
- The lifetime warranty covers cleaning and accent stones under 0.10 carat. Center stones, loss and theft are excluded.
- Its Trustpilot profile is small and unclaimed: 37 reviews and a 4.0 score, with 16% of them at one star.
With Clarity at a Glance
Our verdict: legit, with a home preview that is not free
With Clarity
by With Clarity
Best for: A buyer who wants to see a replica of the design on the hand before paying for the real ring.
With Clarity Inc sells in its own name from New York, is BBB accredited with an A+ rating, and prices every engagement ring as a setting first, with the center stone added on top.
Illustration of the setting type, not a photo of this ring.
What we like
- Free US returns within 30 days of receipt, with an insured prepaid label
- A replica ring can be tried at home for 7 days before ordering the real one
- Publishes its fees in advance: resizing after 30 days, re-engraving, certificate replacement
Keep in mind
- The home preview charges 200 dollars per replica and refunds it as a gift card, not cash
- A resized ring can no longer be returned, even inside the 30 days
- The lifetime warranty excludes center stones, diamonds above 0.10 carat, loss and theft
- Price range
- $558 to $963 for its petite four-prong setting alone, by metal (checked 18/09/2026)
- Material
- Online with one New York showroom; lab-grown and natural diamonds, settings and fine jewelry
- Guarantee
- 30 days from receipt to return; one resize within 30 days; lifetime warranty for small accent stones and cleaning
Who With Clarity Is
With Clarity’s About page says it began in New York City with Anubh and Slisha Kankariya, a couple who found buying an engagement ring “overwhelming, confusing, and outdated”, and that it opened a flagship showroom in SoHo in 2024, at 118 Spring Street. The Better Business Bureau profile fills in what the About page leaves out: With Clarity Inc was incorporated in April 2015, started trading in May 2015, lists Marie Audier as CEO and Slisha Kankariya as marketing director, and gives a second address in Long Island City, Queens. The BBB describes it as “an online, direct to consumer home try-on engagement ring company”.
Most of what it sells is lab-grown: its menus lead with lab diamonds and colored lab diamonds, and it sells natural diamonds as well. Its return terms mention GIA and IGI certificates, and charge 300 dollars if a certificate is not sent back with a return.
The Home Preview: Replicas for a Deposit
The home preview is what makes With Clarity different, and its terms are more specific than its headline. The page’s title reads “Try On Engagement Rings At Home for Free”. The text underneath says that for a Home Preview order, With Clarity “will charge your card” 200 dollars per ring, an amount “fully redeemable” as a gift card of the same value “toward your purchase upon return”. If the replicas are not returned, the charge stays.
So the preview costs nothing only if you then buy from With Clarity. If you try two replicas and decide on a ring elsewhere, you hold 400 dollars in gift cards rather than a refund. The other terms are practical: up to two replicas per order, 7 days to try them, shipping free both ways, US addresses only, and replicas “made to order” that “can take up to 14 business days to craft”. The replicas are “3D-printed made of white metallic alloy and a diamond simulant” and are meant for looking, not wearing. Plan the timing, because two weeks of crafting plus a week of trying comes before the real ring is even ordered, and With Clarity quotes up to 12 business days to ship a finished ring.
The Policies, in Its Own Words
| Policy | What With Clarity writes | Page |
|---|---|---|
| Returns | “eligible for return or exchange within 30 calendar days from the date of your receipt” | Our Policies |
| Where to return | “Returns are not accepted at our With Clarity stores.” | Our Policies |
| Return cost | “Returns for orders from the US are free”, with insurance on the full value | Our Policies |
| Resized rings | Not eligible: “Items that have been submitted for resizing, even if still within the 30-day return period” | Our Policies |
| Outside work | Jewelry “worked on, resized or repaired by another jeweler” cannot be returned | Our Policies |
| Missing certificate | “a reprinting fee” of 300 dollars | Our Policies |
| Resizing | “one free resizing within 30 days of your purchase”, with a 25-dollar “one way FedEx insured shipping fee” in the US | Our Policies |
| Eternity rings | “cannot be resized or exchanged outside our 30-day return policy” | Our Policies |
| Engraving | Free, with a 25-dollar “re-engraving fee” if the ring is later resized or polished | Our Policies |
| Warranty | Free cleaning and replacement of “stones under 0.10ct”; “Center stone diamonds and gemstones on engagement rings are also not covered” | Our Policies |
| Cancellation | “Orders can be cancelled within the first 48 hours.” | Our Policies |
Two Pages, Two Versions of the Repeat-Purchase Rule
With Clarity limits repeat returns, and its two policy pages describe the limit differently. Our Policies says a customer may return “up to two times within 30 days of receipt”, that the second is refunded only as store credit or with “a 20% restocking fee”, and that an account gets three returns, exchanges or cancellations in total. Its Refund Policy page says that after a return, a second purchase within six months “will not be eligible for return”. Both discourage buying several rings to compare and send back. If you might return a ring and buy another, ask which rule applies, in writing, before the second order.
Free Resizing That Ends the Free Return
The resize is free, but in the US it carries a 25-dollar shipping fee one way, and a resized ring can no longer be returned. Rare Carat and Brilliant Earth write the same rule, as our Rare Carat review shows. After 30 days, a resize under one finger size costs shipping plus 30 dollars in 14K gold, 40 in 18K or 50 in platinum, and a bigger change means recrafting the ring for a quoted price. Our guide to ring resizing cost puts those fees in context.
A Warranty for Small Stones, Not the Center Stone
The free lifetime warranty is narrower than its name suggests: it replaces accent stones under 0.10 carat and cleans the ring, and it excludes larger diamonds, the center stone, damage, loss and theft. With Clarity sells a paid “Clarity Commitment” protection plan, whose “Lifetime Plan is a period of 10 years from the date of purchase”. Work by any other jeweler voids the warranty. Loss and theft are a matter for engagement ring insurance.
Prices, by Metal
With Clarity prices engagement rings as a setting first; the center stone is chosen and priced separately. We read the Classic Four Prong Petite Comfort Fit Solitaire on 18 September 2026, from Portugal and again from a US server, and both showed the same US dollar prices.
| Classic Four Prong Petite setting, read 18/09/2026 | Price shown |
|---|---|
| 14K white, yellow or rose gold | 558 dollars, shown against 620 |
| 18K gold, any color | 828 dollars |
| Platinum | 963 dollars |
| What the price covers | “(Setting Only)” |
The site ran a “Fall Sale” of “Up to 25% Off” that day, marked on the products. The setting is only part of the bill, so compare the complete ring, stone included, with the same grades elsewhere. Our guide to diamond ring price by carat shows what a stone of each size usually adds.
What Customers Say, Counted
We read With Clarity’s Trustpilot profile and its BBB profile on 18 September 2026.
| Source, read 18/09/2026 | With Clarity |
|---|---|
| Trustpilot score and reviews | 4.0 from 37 reviews |
| Trustpilot five stars / one star | 81% / 16% |
| Trustpilot labels | “Unclaimed profile”; “No history of asking for reviews” |
| BBB rating and accreditation | A+, accredited since 15 May 2018 |
| BBB complaints | 8 in the last three years, 4 closed in the last 12 months |
| BBB customer reviews | Average of 4.71 from 31 reviews |
The Trustpilot sample is small but not invited, which makes it closer to what unprompted buyers write. The seven reviews at one or two stars, from October 2023 to April 2026, split into three groups by our reading: shipping dates that slipped or a customs delay (3), quality problems such as a necklace that broke on opening and a center stone that rattled (3), and one buyer who says an order was held until they sent a photo of their card and ID (1). The positive reviews mostly name a consultant.
The most recent complaint published on the BBB, from July 2026, says a center stone was found to be of a lower grade than ordered when the ring went back for resizing; With Clarity answered it, and the exchange is on the BBB page. One complaint does not make a pattern, but it is a reason to check the grading report and laser inscription against your order when the ring arrives.
Who With Clarity Suits
| Your situation | With Clarity? | Why |
|---|---|---|
| You want to see a style on the hand first | A good fit | Replicas for 7 days, if you accept the gift card terms |
| You may buy the ring from someone else | Skip the preview | The 200-dollar deposit comes back as store credit |
| You are unsure of the ring size | Plan the order | A resize ends the return; decide first |
| You want lost stones covered | Add cover | The free warranty excludes the center stone and loss |
| You want lab-grown with a named certificate | Ask first | Its terms name GIA and IGI; confirm which your stone has |
| You are comparing online jewelers | Read more than one | See where to buy engagement rings |
If lab-grown is the plan, our comparison of the best place to buy lab-grown diamonds sets several sellers side by side on the same terms. Our Angara review and Brilliant Earth review use the same checks, and every store we have reviewed is listed in our jeweler reviews.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is With Clarity a Legitimate Company?
On the evidence we checked, yes. With Clarity Inc was incorporated in New York in 2015, has a SoHo showroom, and has been BBB accredited since 2018 with an A+ rating. Its policies are written and specific. Its Trustpilot profile is small, 37 reviews, so the BBB record says more.
Why Is With Clarity So Cheap?
We cannot confirm that it is. Its pages give no reason for their prices, and its menus lead with lab-grown diamonds, which usually cost less than mined stones of the same size. On 18 September 2026 its petite four-prong setting alone was 558 dollars in 14K gold, before any stone, during a sale.
Does With Clarity Sell Real Diamonds?
Yes. It sells lab-grown and natural diamonds, and its return terms refer to GIA and IGI certificates. GIA grades laboratory-grown diamonds as diamonds, and the FTC’s 2018 revision of its Jewelry Guides rewrote the definition of “diamond”. Its home preview replicas are not diamonds: they use a simulant.
Is a Lab Grown Diamond Worth Buying?
It depends on what you want from the stone. A lab-grown diamond costs less than a natural one of the same size and grades, and it is a real diamond, but GIA now grades lab stones on a separate scale. Our lab-grown vs natural diamond guide covers what that means.
Sources
- With Clarity, Our Policies, returns, resizing, warranty, home preview, engraving and cancellation, accessed 18/09/2026.
- With Clarity, Refund Policy, undated, accessed 18/09/2026.
- With Clarity, Home Preview, undated, accessed 18/09/2026.
- With Clarity, About Us, undated, accessed 18/09/2026.
- With Clarity, Classic Four Prong Petite Comfort Fit Solitaire Engagement Ring, prices by metal, accessed 18/09/2026.
- Better Business Bureau, With Clarity Inc, Business Profile, including complaints and customer reviews, accessed 18/09/2026.
- Trustpilot, With Clarity Reviews, all 37 reviews, accessed 18/09/2026.
- GIA, GIA Launches Updated Laboratory-Grown Diamond Services October 1, 2025, accessed 18/09/2026.
- Federal Trade Commission, FTC Approves Final Revisions to Jewelry Guides, 2018, accessed 18/09/2026.